Tasting your way through the best sandwiches in Nashville

Every great sandwich’s core is more than just meat, cheeses, and vegetables. While it’s not always easy to put your finger on it, your taste buds know the difference between an okay sandwich and an excellence stacked between two slices (or more) of bread. 

In Nashville, every traveler experiences the quest for the perfect sandwich at one time or another. Music City has incredible options when you’re looking for something quick or just enjoy the simple pleasures of a good sandwich. From sourcing the finest ingredients to perfecting the balance of flavors, these shops are committed to quality that shines through in each mouthful. 

TL;DR: take a quick bite of the best sandwiches in Nashville

Nothing hits the spot like a good sandwich. Here is a snapshot of some of the best sandwich shops in Nashville in our opinion.

• Mitchell Delicatessen: Best for a classic experience
• Fat Belly Pretzel: Best for inventive twists on deli fare
• 51st Deli: Best for a neighborhood feel and build-your-own options
• Bill’s Sandwich Palace: Best for a regal culinary feast
• East Side Bahn Mi: Best for authentic Vietnamese flavors
• Eastwood Deli Co: Best for from-scratch cooking
• Little Hats: Best for big Italian flavors in a cozy setting
• Barebones Butcher: Best for ethical meats and artisanal craftsmanship
• 615 Deli: Best for a warm welcome and diverse menu

Sandwich etiquette: tips for enjoying your meal

Understanding the world of sandwich-eating etiquette can be a bit like unwrapping a layered delicacy––there’s more to it than meets the eye. Here are some tips to ensure your sandwich experience is as delightful as the flavors between the bread:

Mind your manners

Navigating the wild world of sandwich etiquette? Rule #1: Ditch the silverware. Your hands are your best tools when it comes to demolishing that skyscraper of a Reuben. Embrace the chaos and the mustard stains – it’s all part of the sandwich-loving experience!

Avoid the soggy bottom

To stop your sandwich from turning into a soggy mess faster than you can say “ruined lunch,” get crafty with your layering skills. Tuck those juicy tomatoes or slathering’s of sauce snugly between drier buddies, or pick a bread that’s tough enough to handle a little moisture without throwing a mushy meltdown.

Pairing perfection

Just like matching your socks, the right sidekick can level up your sandwich game. Think a snappy pickle wrestling the richness of a pastry-heavy pastrami or a zesty lemonade dancing alongside a tangy chicken salad. Poke your sandwich wizard for their magic combos.

Sides and such

While a sandwich might think it’s all that and a bag of chips on its own, throwing in the right sidekick can catapult your meal from meh to marvelous. Contemplate the charm of a side salad, the crunch of chips, or the warmth of a cup of soup to give your meal that full-circle vibe. And let’s not overlook the power of condiments—a dollop of mustard or a smear of aioli can be the superhero cape your sandwich didn’t know it needed, turning it from just fine to fabulously finger-licking good.

Beverage bliss

Finally, never ever overlook the magic of picking the perfect drink to take your sandwich game to legendary levels. Whether it’s a fizzy soda that dances with your taste buds, a chilled iced tea that whispers sweet nothings to your sandwich, or a craft beer that gives your meal a bear hug, the right beverage is like the cherry on top of a great foodie adventure.

Our favorite shops for the best sandwiches in Nashville

Mitchell Delicatessen

Website: mitchelldeli.com

Address: 1306 McGavock Pike, Nashville, TN 37216

Price Range: $5 – $20

Mitchell Delicatessen isn’t just another sandwich shop; it’s a cornerstone of Nashville’s food scene. This deli combines old-world charm with a commitment to modern innovation. Step inside to be greeted by the aroma of freshly baked bread and the hustle and bustle of sandwich artisans at work. What sets Mitchell Delicatessen apart is its dedication to quality and local ingredients. Each sandwich comes with a side of craftsmanship and care, from the perfectly roasted meats to the house-made condiments. Whether craving a classic Reuben or feeling adventurous, Mitchell Delicatessen is up to the challenge.

Must-try dish: The Turkey Avocado and Bacon sandwich is a crowd favorite. It features tender slices of turkey, creamy avocado, and crispy bacon sandwiched between slices of freshly baked bread.

Fat Belly Pretzel

Website: fatbellypretzel.com

Address: 921 Gallatin Ave, Nashville, TN 37206

Price Range: $

Welcome to Fat Belly Pretzel, far from your typical East Nashville deli – it’s a realm where creativity bursts at the seams. Here, traditional deli delights get a wildly inventive makeover that sets Fat Belly Pretzel in a league of its own. Imagine biting into hand-rolled pretzels, oozing with savory fillings, and sandwiches that tower on bread baked so fresh, it might just have come out of the oven. It’s not just food; it’s a symphony of flavors.

Born amidst the pandemic, Fat Belly Pretzel is the brainchild of Chef Levon Wallace and his family, who transformed their passion into a pop-up sensation. They brought to life pretzels with character, so tasty and uniquely shaped, alongside signature dips that became the talk of local farmers markets. Whether you’re in for a quick grab or a relaxed feast, Fat Belly Pretzel promises an experience that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you pleasantly astonished.

Must-try dish: The Breakfast Sando on a pretzel-potato roll is a delicious way to start your day. It features layers of eggs, cheese, and your choice of savory breakfast meats. Similar to Bill’s Sandwich Palace, their menu often updates with new specials, so it’s a good idea to regularly check their website for the latest offerings!

51st Deli

Website: 51stdeli.com

Address: 1314 51st Ave N, Nashville, TN 37209

Price Range: $

51st Deli is a neighborhood institution in The Nations where locals gather to enjoy good food and company. What sets 51st Deli apart is its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu. You’ll find it here, whether craving a classic deli sandwich or feeling adventurous with a build-your-own creation. It’s not just about the food, but the sense of community permeating every restaurant corner. From the friendly staff to the regulars who call it their second home, 51st Deli is a place to belong.

Must-try dish: The West Nasty sandwich is a local favorite. It features a mouthwatering combination of roast beef, turkey, and all the fixings on freshly baked bread.

Bill’s Sandwich Palace

Website: billssandwichpalace.com

Address: 311 N 16th St, Nashville, TN 37206

Price Range: $

At Bill’s Sandwich Palace, you’ll feel like royalty in a sandwitch kingdom. This majestic establishment takes sandwich-making to new heights with its creative combinations and commitment to quality. From the moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked bread and sizzling meats. With its dedication to customer satisfaction and a menu fit for a king, Bill’s Sandwich Palace reigns supreme in Nashville.

Must-try dish:  The menu undergoes a transformation every two weeks, making it challenging to predict if the dishes we enjoyed will be available during your visit. However, we assure you that whatever is on offer will be exceptional! Kush recently indulged in the “Badass Bill’s Beef,” featuring Bear Creek farms braised chuck roast, caramelized onions, aged cheddar, pickled vegetable giardiniera, horseradish mayo, and garlic butter. Meanwhile, Ana was enamored with the “Sesame Spice Schnitzel Sando Situation,” a delightful combination of sesame spice chicken schnitzel, cucumber, red onion, harissa, tahina, sour cream, and garlic butter toasted on Charpier’s sesame seed bun!

East Side Bahn Mi

Website: eastsidebanhmi.com

Address: 1000 Gallatin Ave, Nashville, TN 37206

Price Range: $

East Side Bahn Mi brings the flavors of Vietnam to Music City. Located among the bustling streets of East Nashville, this snug little spot offers an authentic taste of Vietnamese cuisine with a Nashville twist. From the moment you step inside, you’re transported to the lively streets of Hanoi, with the aroma of sizzling meats and fragrant herbs filling the air. Whether enjoying a classic Bahn Mi sandwich or treating yourself to a steaming bowl of pho, every dish knows how to hit the spot. With its commitment to authenticity and popularity among locals, East Side Bahn Mi is a must-visit destination for food lovers visiting Nashville.

Must-try dish: The Classic Cold Cut Combo Bánh Mì is full of flavors. It features tender slices of meat, crisp vegetables, and zesty pickles nestled in a warm, crusty baguette.

Eastwood Deli Co

Website: eastwooddelico.com

Address: 1896 Eastland Ave, Nashville, TN 37206

Price Range: $

Eastwood Deli Co is a family-owned deli that has become a staple of East Nashville. Everything they serve is made from scratch, and they do it all: specialty sandwich creations, house-made soups, fresh salads, and sweet and savory breakfast options, too. From catering to special events, you can find something to fulfill your craving.

Must-try dish: The chicken salad sandwich is a crowd-pleaser. It features tender chunks of chicken, crisp celery, and tangy mayo between two slices of freshly baked bread. 

Little Hats

Website: littlehatsmarket.com

Address: 1120 4th Ave N, Nashville, TN 37208

Price Range: $

Little Hats is a gem in Germantown that combines authentic Italian flavors with Southern charm. Whether indulging in a classic Italian sandwich, meatball sub, or savoring a house-made pasta dish, every bite will remind you of Italy, even if you’ve never been there. Little Hats is a must-visit destination with its welcoming atmosphere and menu highlights. Make sure to explore their market for some great take-home options. 

Must-try dish: The Mortadella Muffuletta embodies genuine Italian flavors. It features layers of savory Italian meats, tangy olive salad, and creamy cheese on your choice of bread. 

Barebones Butcher

Website: barebonesbutcher.com

Address: 906 51st Ave N, Nashville, TN 37209

Price Range: $

Barebones Butcher is a celebration of quality meats. This butcher shop and deli is a haven for carnivores seeking top-notch cuts and flavorful sandwiches. From the moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted by the sight of expert butchers at work. With its commitment to locally sourced ingredients and sustainable practices, Barebones Butcher offers a dining experience that’s as ethical as it is delicious. You won’t go home hungry if you’re sinking your teeth into a juicy burger or enjoying a hearty sandwich.

Must-try dish: The Cheeseburger is a carnivore’s delight. It features two juicy patties, melted American cheese, and all the fixings on a toasted bun. Yes, technically, a cheeseburger is still a sandwich.

615 Deli

Website: https://www.facebook.com/p/615-Deli-100081772189023/

Address: 1703 Portland Ave B, Nashville, TN 37212

Price Range: $

615 Deli offers a menu brimming with delicious delights. This deli is a huge hit with Belmont students, so be ready for a little wait during the school year. The wait is worth it. From traditional deli sandwiches to burritos, burgers, and salads, deciding what to order is no easy task. Luckily, they can wrap up a second sandwich for later to go. 

Must-try dish: The breakfast reubens are a crowd favorite, with fluffy eggs, corned beef, and more. Also don’t skip on there amazing breakfast burritos! 

Exploring more of Nashville

While Nashville’s sandwich scene is undeniably impressive, there’s much more to discover beyond delis and eateries. While you’re wandering through Music City, make sure to check out some of the other cool spots that go great with a tasty sandwich.. After gulping down one of these incredible meals, take some time to go on a walk, do some shopping, or grab a frozen treat from one of our many ice cream shops. From cozy coffee shops serving up artisanal brews to busy food markets offering a taste of local flavors, there’s something for every palate in Nashville.

Ready to taste the best sandwiches in Nashville? Book your stay today

Now that you’ve whetted your appetite for Nashville’s fully loaded sandwiches, it’s time to plan your visit to Music City to experience it all for yourself. At Nashville Luxury Stay, we’re here to make your trip unforgettable with luxury accommodations to suit every traveler. From cozy apartments in the heart of downtown to spacious stays close to your favorite neighborhood, our properties are the perfect home base for your Nashville adventure. Book your stay with us and prepare for a trip you won’t soon forget. 

Experience Nashville like a local and indulge in everything this city has to offer. Whether you’re savoring a mouthwatering sandwich or exploring the hidden gems of Music City, there’s no shortage of unforgettable experiences waiting for you in Nashville. Start planning your trip today and get ready to taste the flavors of Nashville like never before.